I enjoyed so much and learned a lot on this traditional round-table discussion from the noble and Nobel minds of these wonderful scientists! I observe one commonality among them: the passion to discover something new within their respective chosen sphere of science and interest and use it for the benefit of mankind! During their discussion, I sensed out the profound concern each one has on climate change which serves to affirm its reality and the urgency to mitigate it on a global scale. At the concluding remarks, I find it inspiring and encouraging as most of them affirms personally to continue working on their chosen field for as long as they can which is a time-tested effective way to discover something new, while noting on the need to address the here-and-now human needs and concerns as well! Thank you.
I had the privilege of meeting Didier Queloz when he came to my school to give a talk. I was one of the few students invited to have lunch and talk with him. Very down to earth and charismatic person, extremely knowledgeable but he was able to explain difficult concepts in a way in which I could understand. I'm very happy to see that he has won a nobel prize. Thoroughly deserved.
Having spent 51 yrs as the daughter of a brilliant research chemist (albeit not a Nobel Prize winner) I can not tell you the amount of joy I felt listening to these Laureates. You can take the person out of the laboratory, but never take the laboratory out of the person. I would listen to my father for hours on end and never tire. It made no matter that I couldn't understand most of what he was saying!!! I truly thank you all.
@Surya Putchala Hi, I should admit that these special words made me speechless and made my day.. Your father is the one needed to bright the future generation. I hope you nice future
yeah, you could become one, just try to find your domain(field ), and then discover new things. The key is to stay persistence over a prolonged period of time.
I graduated in 6 months. Do it!! It's been fun but you have to choose a cause and science you are most passionate about or it can be a drag. I am ecology, I love it but I HATE my biomedical classes, hate it. Do a science that makes you passionate or science can be the most boring, tedious job on earth.
I have been waiting for this prestigious round-table since last year. This planet needs more such Nobel minds and human beings. I wish these laureates a very happy Christmas and a progressive new year ahead. May you all stay healthy and blessed.
I personally preferred the 2017 format in which the Nobel Laureates were given a lot more time to interact amongst each other wherein the conversation just flowed without much mediation. This format seems a lot moe like a news panel mediated by an anchor.
@vinod ep you clearly don't belong in any of these conversations based on your language. She has a job to do maybe you can get that through your lil brain.
I share your view. But again, like you put it, it's personal preference. The 2017 discussion was calmer and had a lot of elderly people who are given to less talk. This has more young people, probably given to more talk😀. By and large they are all lovely inspiring discussions. They have done well in their fields of study.
Except 2017 also garnered a lot of dislike and criticism. Personally I believe 2017's format was the right way to go. What it lacked was more time. These discussions need time to go into detail and go deeper. It's too rushed to broach big problems in a time period less than a single university lecture!
I love the winners, but i am so happy and proud of the hostess for being smart enough to develop dialogue amongst just a diverse and intelligent group of guest you could think of.
So grateful for this round table. We honestly need each of the Nobel Laureates to go on Joe Rogan & many other podcast shows. Spread the knowledge far & wide.
It was a wonderful meeting!💚💚💚 The ending should be a happy memory. The more I understand the Nobel Prize, The more I respect and admire Nobel Minds Thank you for your kindness
Notable noble assembly,! Creat awareness, really fine to listen to noble laureates who have expressed their views about their works, congratulations, thanks for uploading such masterpieces,
A 16 years old girl influenced this conference so much and it's amazing how much attention she brought to this crisis. I love how the other laureates stood up for the facts. So much respect
I love what you learn about their personalities and discoveries in such a short period of time. Physicists incredibly impressive intellectually, economists in their wisdom and others in their experimentation.
6:43 His words alone vibrates my mind. I love listening to older people because the wisdom they have from just living and then studying the world and their inner world. Very beautiful indeed.
Wow I’m surprised to know about the efforts that she was able to do and see the humanitarian support especially mentioning El Salvador with her mother going there to help the children 💙😭
I don't know why but I watched the whole video with a smile on my face.. Probably because I can understand what they are discussing and not coming across like aliens.. shows their greatness
Very good discussion. I wish to Noble Prize laureates could visit our schools and interact with our younger generations who are our future leaders. It's seen to be an elitist club unreachable to local communities in my country.
As a means to improve my personal social interactions and challenge myself to think, and absorb knowledge, and ideas from great minds and people motivated by improving the well-being of the world....... I love tuning in to these discussions....... I'm grateful for everyone that gives of their time to share their knowledge with us. THANK YOU! Everytime I watch one of these events I enjoy the intellectually stimulating conversation and challenged to think. My thirst for knowledge leaves me wanting more, but I'm grateful for whatever time and frequency everyone is willing to share. Many more of these would be nice.
Nicely curated video with the greatest intellectual people present on the planet sitting at a round table discussing about their work and present situation of the world & the future.. The Round table... should definitely be of larger format of at least 2 hours or more.
Physics is reality.. Dr James Peebles is the real or miningfull knowledgeable person... I love his ideas and suggestions and comments about climate change.
For the first time in my life I watched a 47min youtube video and heard every second of it. This video is just pure celebration of mankind and our civilisation.
@Vivek Tiwari You are quite right, though Nobel laureate Dr. Banerjee may not agree to many of the policies of the BJP government but the Mr. Modi govt did appoint him on advisory panel ,just as Dr. Raghuram Rajan was appointed as the chairman of RBI. Dr.Banerjee is more interested in improving the socioeconomic conditions of India population through this own study matter. It is a different issue that political decisions come to be later on, based on huge wasteful capital expenditure both in Public / private sector leading to the problem of Non - performing- assets ( NPA).
Dude you're talking about being less popular when his one statement against government economic policy can make him the center of all Indians ridicule...all awards outta the window 😂 PS sorry for the generalisation, I know there are exceptions
Thanks a lot for presenting this World Parliament on Human Minds - how do we have to take scientific endeavour for welfare of humanism and mechanism for understanding ourselves for what do we aspire ! The lady coordinating these mysterious minds coming out at the discussion , deserves all appreciation for handling the hard hands very beautifully and wonderfully, looking expressively charming ! May we grow more like this
I still enjoy this gathering of modest and knowledgeable people joyous. however the previous format where laureates engaged in conversation with each other was much better. like the historic conversation of Higgs and his fellow physicist in 2013 session
Prof. Didier Quelez is just curious,funny and excited like a small kid. He never let the child inside him go away as he grew up and thats the best thing to watch.
What I understand from these most educated people is not to be sure all the time ,they don't necessarily conclude but they always highlight to study things more.
Ms Zainab is fantastic, very skillful job to run the conversation naturally and still make sure everyone gets a chance and whole program limits to 50minutes
@Marco Martins Azevedo Throughout history regionalism has been the means by which if you rank all the regions then the influential people leading the "worst" region, by whatever measure, are allowed to continue their regessive ways.
Or be taught by them or do research in them- just do decent in school - high school or college. That's it. Just want it, listen, all question. Scientific careers are straightforward, free.
Golden 47 mins or maybe 1hr+ with my pauses. I enjoyed the communications rather than trying to think of their points, i might need to see it again but its worth it. This is amazing!
This is the best table free from all political influence... And they are thinking not only a particular community, race, religion or country but also whole world... This is real humanity....
From my part I wish that the greatest man of the 20th century Mahatha Gandhi should have been given the Nobel Prize for Peace.Because his was the struggle that stood unstintingly for truth & non- violence.He was an epitome of humbleness & inspite of the great burden on him he had a sense of humour. It was because non- violence was so imbibed in him that even the mighty world British empire were flummoxed by his peaceful movement.
“There is a cult of ignorance in the United States, and there has always been. The strain of anti-intellectualism has been a constant thread winding its way through our political and cultural life, nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that 'my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.” ― Issac Asimov
The year is 2030 : they finally realise we want a full 5 hour discussion. jesus christ give us the long form discussion , we can handle it and want to hear it. 40 minutes isnt enough to understand most people , nevermind the works of multiple nobel prize winners.
31:30 min Nobel Laureate in Physics. Sounds like thoughtful contemplation and rational thinking presented in a manner inline with the reasoned content. That's right, the speaker and the content of their speech, sound like, look like, and seem like that of a Nobel mind. I'm not sure it feels Iike the same could be said for some in some parts of the discussion. Peace.
Don't miss Nobel Minds 2022 with this year's class of laureates. See it here: kzclip.net/video/LutI8YqJkqM/бейне.html
I enjoyed so much and learned a lot on this traditional round-table discussion from the noble and Nobel minds of these wonderful scientists! I observe one commonality among them: the passion to discover something new within their respective chosen sphere of science and interest and use it for the benefit of mankind! During their discussion, I sensed out the profound concern each one has on climate change which serves to affirm its reality and the urgency to mitigate it on a global scale. At the concluding remarks, I find it inspiring and encouraging as most of them affirms personally to continue working on their chosen field for as long as they can which is a time-tested effective way to discover something new, while noting on the need to address the here-and-now human needs and concerns as well! Thank you.
“The greatest enemy of knowledge is not ignorance, it is the illusion of knowledge.”
³@Manu John
@Tike Myson hahahhhahhaahahha nic one m8
@KamikazeRob505 stephen hawking
That's a great line
That’s the same thing lol. Being confident in your ignorance means you have the illusion of knowledge.
I had the privilege of meeting Didier Queloz when he came to my school to give a talk. I was one of the few students invited to have lunch and talk with him. Very down to earth and charismatic person, extremely knowledgeable but he was able to explain difficult concepts in a way in which I could understand. I'm very happy to see that he has won a nobel prize. Thoroughly deserved.
I can say only one thing... you were very fortunate. And I am hailing from Prof Banerjee's home city, Kolkata.
he really seems very charismatic
And maybe you're the next one to sit with him
6:40 "I base my career on curiosity ..." Wise words.
Thanks to Nobel for fillming and posting this video for all to watch online!
I am so glad that I live in Stockholm and Sweden ❤️❤️
Having spent 51 yrs as the daughter of a brilliant research chemist (albeit not a Nobel Prize winner) I can not tell you the amount of joy I felt listening to these Laureates.
You can take the person out of the laboratory, but never take the laboratory out of the person.
I would listen to my father for hours on end and never tire. It made no matter that I couldn't understand most of what he was saying!!!
I truly thank you all.
@Surya Putchala Hi, I should admit that these special words made me speechless and made my day.. Your father is the one needed to bright the future generation. I hope you nice future
Such an honor! I had a similar experience with my father who was a scientist. The awe and inspiration they provide their kids is priceless!!
As the saying goes, "I like your funny words magic man."
The Noble Minds series inspires me more to become a scientist myself. Hats off to all the laureates and their incredible achievements.
@Muhammad Raffay I'm so proud to see these comments that prove how the future generation will shine as a bright star.
hey, what are you working on
Go for it Ishani.... The world needs more people like you
yeah, you could become one, just try to find your domain(field ), and then discover new things. The key is to stay persistence over a prolonged period of time.
I graduated in 6 months.
Do it!!
It's been fun but you have to choose a cause and science you are most passionate about or it can be a drag.
I am ecology, I love it but I HATE my biomedical classes, hate it.
Do a science that makes you passionate or science can be the most boring, tedious job on earth.
One thing I take away from all those Nobel Minds conversations is passion. They really enjoy doing what they do and the prize is just a byproduct.
conversations between elevated minds always inspire...!!! it was a great experience listening to them..!!!
I always walk away wanting more. :-)
I have been waiting for this prestigious round-table since last year. This planet needs more such Nobel minds and human beings. I wish these laureates a very happy Christmas and a progressive new year ahead. May you all stay healthy and blessed.
Wow.. what an incredible round table. Thank you Nobel for doing this show. Also the reporter really upgraded her performance this year.
@Irene Choe Zeinab Badawi
Agreed. Anyone knows her name?
I personally preferred the 2017 format in which the Nobel Laureates were given a lot more time to interact amongst each other wherein the conversation just flowed without much mediation. This format seems a lot moe like a news panel mediated by an anchor.
@vinod ep you clearly don't belong in any of these conversations based on your language. She has a job to do maybe you can get that through your lil brain.
Agreed
@Luka Host was an ass in that but the conversation or even the direction it was going was far more interesting than this one
I share your view. But again, like you put it, it's personal preference. The 2017 discussion was calmer and had a lot of elderly people who are given to less talk. This has more young people, probably given to more talk😀. By and large they are all lovely inspiring discussions. They have done well in their fields of study.
Except 2017 also garnered a lot of dislike and criticism. Personally I believe 2017's format was the right way to go. What it lacked was more time. These discussions need time to go into detail and go deeper. It's too rushed to broach big problems in a time period less than a single university lecture!
I can listen to them for hours, massive respect for them.
I love the winners, but i am so happy and proud of the hostess for being smart enough to develop dialogue amongst just a diverse and intelligent group of guest you could think of.
This is so amazing to be able to watch such an amazing talk! I am incredibly grateful to this opportunity!
So grateful for this round table. We honestly need each of the Nobel Laureates to go on Joe Rogan & many other podcast shows. Spread the knowledge far & wide.
It was a wonderful meeting!💚💚💚
The ending should be a happy memory.
The more I understand the Nobel Prize,
The more I respect and admire Nobel Minds
Thank you for your kindness
45:40 harnessing passion. It's just so much fun and inspiring to see these legends are still passionate and full of curiosity
I have made it a habit to watch every edition of this interview a year since 2017.
Forever blown by these great minds. Humanity thanks you.
It feels warm to listen brilliant minds
Notable noble assembly,!
Creat awareness, really fine to listen to noble laureates who have expressed their views about their works, congratulations, thanks for uploading such masterpieces,
Great platform to see n hear the laureates share their their views together, fortunate to hear them n congratulations to them.
A 16 years old girl influenced this conference so much and it's amazing how much attention she brought to this crisis. I love how the other laureates stood up for the facts. So much respect
I love what you learn about their personalities and discoveries in such a short period of time. Physicists incredibly impressive intellectually, economists in their wisdom and others in their experimentation.
4:00 I loved how she handled forgetting his name and peeking down at the paper. Absolutely hilarious
Nice! 😁 Zeinab is a brilliant presenter. Not caring what the critics have to say about her.
6:43
His words alone vibrates my mind.
I love listening to older people because the wisdom they have from just living and then studying the world and their inner world.
Very beautiful indeed.
Wow I’m surprised to know about the efforts that she was able to do and see the humanitarian support especially mentioning El Salvador with her mother going there to help the children 💙😭
I don't know why but I watched the whole video with a smile on my face.. Probably because I can understand what they are discussing and not coming across like aliens.. shows their greatness
THE MOST HONOURABLE ROUND TABLE CONFERENCE EVER. ..HATS OFF! !!
really , i would say last year the round table was much more interesting to listen to, also 2017 was *much* more catching the attention.
This seems like one of the happiest round tables out of all the previous ones in a while.
Thank you for an interesting video. It is great to hear all the different opinions and perspectives of Nobel prize candidates/winners.
Very good discussion.
I wish to Noble Prize laureates could visit our schools and interact with our younger generations who are our future leaders. It's seen to be an elitist club unreachable to local communities in my country.
30:50
That's the most profound moment at this juncture of time.
Very well said professor.
As a means to improve my personal social interactions and challenge myself to think, and absorb knowledge, and ideas from great minds and people motivated by improving the well-being of the world....... I love tuning in to these discussions....... I'm grateful for everyone that gives of their time to share their knowledge with us. THANK YOU! Everytime I watch one of these events I enjoy the intellectually stimulating conversation and challenged to think. My thirst for knowledge leaves me wanting more, but I'm grateful for whatever time and frequency everyone is willing to share. Many more of these would be nice.
It's wonderful 🥰 thank you to great minds
Their passion is an inspiration.
Nicely curated video with the greatest intellectual people present on the planet sitting at a round table discussing about their work and present situation of the world & the future..
The Round table... should definitely be of larger format of at least 2 hours or more.
Physics is reality.. Dr James Peebles is the real or miningfull knowledgeable person... I love his ideas and suggestions and comments about climate change.
I love that their mothers instilled in them the desire to help others.
Remarkable interview with beautiful minds and excellent mediator. Many thanks.
"We are designed for this planet" Beautifully said.
For the first time in my life I watched a 47min youtube video and heard every second of it. This video is just pure celebration of mankind and our civilisation.
You all inspire us every single day.
People like Mr. Banerjee are less known in India and politicians are more famous. Sad.
@Vivek Tiwari You are quite right, though Nobel laureate Dr. Banerjee may not agree to many of the policies of the BJP government but the Mr. Modi govt did appoint him on advisory panel ,just as Dr. Raghuram Rajan was appointed as the chairman of RBI. Dr.Banerjee is more interested in improving the socioeconomic conditions of India population through this own study matter. It is a different issue that political decisions come to be later on, based on huge wasteful capital expenditure both in Public / private sector leading to the problem of Non - performing- assets ( NPA).
@Trinita Singha Roy I swear... 🤣
@আমি রাহুল 👍👏
Yup...
Bordering on being named part of tukde tukde and anti-national by know alls of our Govt
Dude you're talking about being less popular when his one statement against government economic policy can make him the center of all Indians ridicule...all awards outta the window 😂
PS sorry for the generalisation, I know there are exceptions
Noble minds focused on Noble work. Checking and tweaking that economic development actually trickles down to the needy. Much success to all three
Thanks a lot for presenting this
World Parliament on Human
Minds - how do we have to take scientific endeavour for
welfare of humanism and
mechanism for understanding
ourselves for what do we aspire !
The lady coordinating these
mysterious minds coming out
at the discussion , deserves all
appreciation for handling the
hard hands very beautifully and
wonderfully, looking expressively charming !
May we grow more like this
Some of the smartest people of the human species. I look at them in awe.
Together
BBC, Zeinab Badawi and Nobel Minds 2019, together we are strong.
They should do something like this for awardees of one subject over a decade or so...
Really smart
This discussion is best thing I've seen so far in 2020.
I still enjoy this gathering of modest and knowledgeable people joyous. however the previous format where laureates engaged in conversation with each other was much better. like the historic conversation of Higgs and his fellow physicist in 2013 session
what a beautiful round table conference !!!!
It is
This was awesome to watch. It shows you how complicated climate change is. But thankfully we have these scientists who are trying to figure it out
It's all good with fun and inspiring words and views from the great people
36:28 The beauty of science. When we don't know, we say we don't know.
Then the continuation of the journey to discovery continues.
@Liberus Scientists, I assume
That's what we are almost always saying in genuine literature. It's how you say you don't know that counts.
Really very beatiful.....he haven't made an argument saying no or yes but make us curious that there may be life outside.
@Liberus humans
Prof. Didier Quelez is just curious,funny and excited like a small kid. He never let the child inside him go away as he grew up and thats the best thing to watch.
OMG< please make more videos like this! TRUE GEMS
Loved this; you're inspiring.
What I understand from these most educated people is not to be sure all the time ,they don't necessarily conclude but they always highlight to study things more.
You see how humble they are but ready to stand up to what they believe in. Im trying to be like that.
Beautiful, nice series. I‘m interested to see all the deeper details about that.👍☺️😌
Loved the little physics-economics exchange from 17:26
Great discussion. Thank you all.
Ms Zainab is fantastic, very skillful job to run the conversation naturally and still make sure everyone gets a chance and whole program limits to 50minutes
Great minds and great discussions. Time was short. It could have been extended to 1 hour.
This needed to be 10 hours long!!
Taking inspiration because I have medicine paper tomorrow 😂😂🔥🔥next level discussion 💯
Really it was so inspiring conversation. .. i m amused to watch this fantastic thoughts of laureates .
I look forward to getting the NOBEL PRIZE one day 💙💙🤗
sometimes sometimesnot it’s a new era bud, get used to it
Well I suppose, hope is really important even though it is ridiculous. I would never even imagine myself winning a nobel prize.
@Kaan Arslan sometimes they do, sometimes not :)
🤷♀️
Nobel prize holders don't express themselves via emojis.
Outstanding discussion !
Imagine a table like that could decide on global matters. I wonder how earth would look like now?!
Its a shame we can only imagine...
Probably the same as it is now
@Robert Remuszka 💯💯💯
Become a person like that and then become a world leader then set the standard
@Marco Martins Azevedo Throughout history regionalism has been the means by which if you rank all the regions then the influential people leading the "worst" region, by whatever measure, are allowed to continue their regessive ways.
This one's a fun bunch. Lesser ego friction, more unity and openness.
i love geniuses I'm proud to be of the same species
It feels so Great my Country, KENYA, being mentioned here. What challenge to people like for doing a PhD in economics.
The only table I would actually want to sit at. What an honor! 💕
Or be taught by them or do research in them- just do decent in school - high school or college. That's it. Just want it, listen, all question. Scientific careers are straightforward, free.
When we believe in science we can feel the Singularity of knowledge and wisdom from myriad of fields!
physics and science is sometimes a bit difficult to follow, But I found this fairly easy to follow..... Hope they do many more of these,
Wish i had professors like these
Well, if you want to pay for a $100.000 for college
This is very prestigious. I love watching this.
Inspiring minds!
very entertaining , love it
Golden 47 mins or maybe 1hr+ with my pauses. I enjoyed the communications rather than trying to think of their points, i might need to see it again but its worth it. This is amazing!
I really love that video! Thank you so much!
Love the conversation flow.
Esnther duflo and Abhijeet Banerjee are such relationship goals 😍☺️
But the whole discussion gives me so much hope
Marvelous conversation!
This is the best table free from all political influence... And they are thinking not only a particular community, race, religion or country but also whole world... This is real humanity....
From my part I wish that the greatest man of the 20th century Mahatha Gandhi should have been given the Nobel Prize for Peace.Because his was the struggle that stood unstintingly for truth & non- violence.He was an epitome of humbleness & inspite of the great burden on him he had a sense of humour. It was because non- violence was so imbibed in him that even the mighty world British empire were flummoxed by his peaceful movement.
Their Mother - Role Model for 3 Noble Minds 2019..🙏 🙏 🙏
Inspiring 🙌
Awesome, I’ve been waiting for this.
They all are brilliant
I enjoyed the 2017 event. It has more interaction and better explanation.
“There is a cult of ignorance in the United States, and there has always been. The strain of anti-intellectualism has been a constant thread winding its way through our political and cultural life, nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that 'my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.”
― Issac Asimov
@Boxer Pete All other developed countries
Cult of ignorance, but compared to what countries?
The year is 2030 : they finally realise we want a full 5 hour discussion. jesus christ give us the long form discussion , we can handle it and want to hear it. 40 minutes isnt enough to understand most people , nevermind the works of multiple nobel prize winners.
You are indeed a rockstar Professor
I wish i was sitting ar this Table!
Respected ma'am,
Thank you for sharing.
31:30 min Nobel Laureate in Physics.
Sounds like thoughtful contemplation and rational thinking presented in a manner inline with the reasoned content. That's right, the speaker and the content of their speech, sound like, look like, and seem like that of a Nobel mind. I'm not sure it feels Iike the same could be said for some in some parts of the discussion. Peace.
finally reading this! he was ignored on purpose as he sounded rational and against the current.
Weird that someone called him a heretic.
This is the best of the best each separated by thousands of miles and religious beliefs but science finds a way!